Friday, April 10, 2009

Is the End of Good Design Near?


First let me say I never thought I would be saying this - "there's a downfall to producing good design". Go ahead read it again. It appears that by producing really well designed work for the same amount of money or less then what a company was previously spending to produce crap is a bad thing.

This is a fight that has slowly been developing over the last couple of years. By working with my clients and knowing what our overall budgets are upfront I am able to produce much better work then their previous firm. It's not that my design services are necessarily cheap, but I truly am concerned about my clients getting a useful end product. I would rather make sure we are spending some money on photography or illustration instead of using stock and keeping the rest for myself. I would rather see the project be printed on a paper that makes the project pop, then have to go to cheap coated stock. I'm willing to sacrifice a little on my end to make a project great.

So many people these days want the perception to be that it was cheap to produce, regardless of if it really is. If it's perceived as cheap then there will be no questions from the board, or their bosses or their stock holders. Too many times recently I've heard it looks too expensive. How do you fight that philosophy? I understand where my client is coming from - I understand that they have to answer to a higher power, but how does this make their company better? How does it help them to advance their initiative? Since when did being mediocre become something to aspire to? It's a sad day, not just for design, for all businesses. It's sad when as an individual you are looked down upon for being successful. It's even more sad when as a business you are shunned for wanting to lead the pack. My sweet America mediocrity appears to be our destiny.

I remember when looking at the bottom line meant something. When doing the best you could was expected. I remember when I wanted to get out of bed in the morning, because I was dying to do something great. I wish, I hope that as we walk down this road more people will appreciate what used to be. Don't get me wrong, I love my clients and I'll still fight for good ideas, but I hate this new social conscience that a select few in this country has chosen to project on all of us. Damn it, I want to be successful, I want to want to get out of bed in the morning, I want to lead the pack and most of all I want to produce good design.

3 comments:

Anonymous said...

sadly design has become a commodity more then ever... and it's become such an overwhelming storm at this point (due to cheap stock, cheap digital printing, etc) that im not sure its a war worth waging... that said im not giving up. it's just time to change the battlefield.

Ed McDonald said...

Welcome to my world. The world of photography went down that road several years ago and has not yet made it back. The road where clients are "OK" with subpar stock photographs because it's quick, easy, cheap and by golly "good enough". Since when is good enough really good enough? The quality threshold has really reached new lows. Too bad, B/C I think there is much work that can be done on great levels, but only if you have intelligent clients who get it.

Chris J said...

Well said Ed. I completely agree. I've actually gotten to a point that I'm willing to do what I can (illustration) to make it work for the client. I would rather have to spend a little extra of my own time to make the piece better. Of course I'm not a photographer so I would never try to take my own photos and use them...